As the 2025 MLB season unfolds, Pittsburgh Pirates fans find themselves navigating a complex landscape of hope, frustration, and unwavering loyalty.
A Promising Start with Paul Skenes
The season began with high expectations, largely centered around sophomore sensation Paul Skenes. After a stellar rookie year in 2024, where he posted an 11–3 record with a 1.96 ERA and 170 strikeouts, Skenes was named the Opening Day starter for 2025. His early performances have been impressive, including a six-inning, nine-strikeout shutout against the Dodgers on April 26. (Wikipedia) Skenes himself expressed optimism about the team's cohesion, stating, "The thing that fires me up the most this year is that we have a lot of buy-in. It just feels different." (MLB Analysis Network)
A Challenging Stretch
Despite Skenes' contributions, the Pirates have faced a difficult stretch. From April 27 to May 7, the team suffered multiple losses, including a 9–2 defeat to the Dodgers and a 5–0 shutout by the Cardinals. These results have tested the patience of a fan base eager for a turnaround. (SI) A recent SB Nation Reacts survey indicated that while nearly 50% of fans anticipated improvement in 2025, the team's current performance has tempered expectations. (Bucs Dugout)
Ownership Under Scrutiny
Frustration has also been directed toward team ownership. Critics, including Yankees broadcaster Michael Kay, have highlighted the Pirates' lack of significant investment in player acquisitions, noting that the team hasn't signed a multi-year free-agent contract since 2016. This perceived reluctance to spend has led to questions about the organization's commitment to building a competitive roster around talents like Skenes. (New York Post)
Controversy Over Clemente Mural
Adding to the discontent, the Pirates faced backlash after replacing a mural of Hall of Famer Roberto Clemente with an alcohol advertisement at PNC Park. Clemente's family expressed their disappointment over the decision, leading the team to apologize and commit to restoring the tribute. (People.com)
Enduring Fan Support
Despite these challenges, fan support remains steadfast. Events like PiratesFest have showcased the community's enthusiasm, with players acknowledging the positive energy. Outfielder Bryan Reynolds remarked, "You just feel everyone's excitement for the season; you build off that." (SI)
As the season progresses, the Pirates' faithful continue to hope for a resurgence, buoyed by emerging stars and a shared desire to see the team return to postseason contention.
